The
intersectionality of political identity versus sex and gender generates
combative rhetoric, and UNC Greensboro witnessed such conflict in 2004. PRIDE Week
traditionally takes place in March or April on UNC Greensboro’s campus.[1] PRIDE Week was sponsored by
the UNC Greensboro student group, PRIDE[2], and
included events such as a picnic by a lake, PRIDE Prom, and a student drag show
(co-sponsored by the Residence Hall Association), featuring a silent auction
and bake sale. The scheduled keynote speaker for UNCG PRIDE Week 2004 was Debra
Davis, a retired transgender high school librarian who was executive director
of the Gender Education Center.[3] These events were typical of PRIDE Weeks at UNC Greensboro, but the publicity of the week
of 2004 was to be unlike that of the past festivities.
Intentionally
scheduled to compete with PRIDE Week, the newly formed UNC Greensboro College Republicans
scheduled Morality Week at the same time. In the words of a UNC Greensboro senior
and member of the College Republicans, “We want to show that there is a large
section of society that is not happy with the perverse and degrading change in
culture over the past 50 years.”[4] Morality Week began with an affirmative action bake sale, continued with
events such as “Right to Life Day,” “No Hump Day,”[5] and a barbecue. The College
Republicans selected the University of North Carolina at Wilmington professor,
Mike Adams, as their keynote speaker.
The selection and funding of Adams as a speaker caused scandal, as
accusations were made by the College Republicans that UNC Greensboro was refusing funding
for the conservative speaker and Morality Week events. Argument became
especially bitter after Adams wrote an article labeling the university as UNC
Gomorrah[6] for
funding a lecture by feminist author, photographer, and pornographer, Tristan
Taormino, that February. [7]
College Republican
chairman, Travis Billingsley, claimed that the student organization was misled
purposefully into not filling out an allocation form in order that Morality
Week would not receive funds. It was ironic that the College Republicans
claimed the lack of funding was overt discrimination, as Jason Crawford,
presidential candidate for the College Republicans in 2004, argued for the
cutting or elimination of PRIDE’s budget over their Black History Month book display in 2002.[8] As
heated debate ensued, the UNC Greensboro Office of Student Life assisted the College
Republicans in obtaining $2000 to support their events.[9] When asked why the Office of
Student Life decided to step in to offer funding to the College Republicans,
Assistant Director of Student Life, Checka Leinwall, stated, “A college campus
is one of the hallmark market places of ideas. Morality Week will give our
students an opportunity to look at different points of
view.” [10]
There was great
concern on campus about protests that might occur between organizers at both
PRIDE and Morality Week events. The College Republicans’ affirmative action
bake sale saw protesters from the UNCG Socialists, UNCG Universalist
Unitarians, the NAACP, the UNCG Neo-Black Society, and even a few North
Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University students. There was no
report of UNCG PRIDE and the College Republican members protesting each other’s
events. According to Michael Bishop, business manager of PRIDE, “We have
decided to take the high road. They [the College Republicans] have a right to
have it. It is a slap in the face that they are having it in the same week.”[11] Melissa Holland, the Student Government PRIDE representative, went so far as to
suggest “The College Republicans should come to some of our events and listen
to what we have to say instead of judging us from a far, and we should do the
same.” [12]
Both UNC Greensboro PRIDE
and the College Republicans considered their respective events successful. Many
people were offended, but there was no report of violence. The significance of
this clash of politics versus sexuality and gender on a North Carolina
university campus, though it did not seem of great importance at the time, is a
foreshadowing of the future. In a few years, North Carolina would receive international
attention relating to the state government’s stance on marriage equality and
trans issues. PRIDE Week versus Morality Week at UNC Greensboro was a small taste of the
controversy that would draw the UNC system universities into news headlines
with events that are still unfolding.
[1] UNC Greensboro commemorates PRIDE Week in March, as
opposed to June, because the spring semester ends in May, therefore most
students would not have the opportunity to celebrate. In 2004, UNC Greensboro PRIDE Week
was celebrated from March 18th to March 26th.
[2] As of 2016, the UNC Greensboro LGBTQ student
organization changed its name to the Queer Student Union.
[3] Hilary Hellens, “PRIDE Week Rolls along According to
Schedule,” The Carolinian, Feb. 18, 2002,
UA42.4.01, Martha Blakeney Hodges Special Collections and University Archives,
University of North Carolina at Greensboro, NC, USA.
[4] Eren Tartaragasi, “Affirmative Action Bake Sale Draws Fire,” The
Carolinian, Feb. 18, 2002, UA42.4.01, Martha Blakeney Hodges Special
Collections and University Archives, University of North Carolina at
Greensboro, NC, USA.
[5] The College Republicans arranged a presenter
to speak on sexual abstinence.
[6] It should be noted that the first Gomorrah
reference made to UNC Greensboro is recorded in a letter from disgruntled alumna from
1979.
Mike S. Adams,
“Welcome to UNC Gomorrah,” Townhall,
March 1, 2004. Accessed Oct. 17, 2017. https://townhall.com/columnists/mikeadams/2004/03/01/welcome-to-unc-gomorrah-n1284950
[7] There was a perception that Taormino’s
lecture was funded officially by UNC Greensboro, using taxpayer money. It was not. The
funding was aloccated from student fees all incoming students at UNC Greensboro pay,
portions of which are distributed to student groups and student services.
Joe Killian, “Sex Lecturer’s UNCG Visit Sparks
Debate,” Greensboro News and Record
(Greensboro, NC), March 21, 2004.
[8] Joe Wilbur and John W. Ayers, “PRIDE under Siege,” The
Carolinian, March 4, 2002, UA42.4.01, Martha Blakeney Hodges Special
Collections and University Archives, University of North Carolina at
Greensboro, NC, USA.
[9] Anna Liles, “College Republicans Get Money, Support
from OSL,” The Carolinian, March 18, 2004,
UA42.4.01, Martha Blakeney Hodges Special Collections and University Archives,
University of North Carolina at Greensboro, NC, USA.
[10] Ibid.
[11] Hilary Hellens, “PRIDE Week Rolls along According to
Schedule,” The Carolinian, Feb. 18, 2002,
UA42.4.01, Martha Blakeney Hodges Special Collections and University Archives,
University of North Carolina at Greensboro, NC, USA.
[12] Ibid.